McDonald's shares closed more than 6% higher on Wednesday after the company reported third-quarter results. Investors clearly liked what they saw, but a closer reading of the numbers suggests the rally is running ahead of the evidence about the chain's core market.
The strongest part of the quarter came from abroad. Same-store sales rose 1.5% overall, above the 1.3% increase analysts expected according to StreetAccount. The international developmental licensed markets business, which includes Japan and China, posted 4.2% growth against a forecast of 2.1%. That is a genuine bright spot, and it is the main reason the headline numbers look better than the domestic picture.
The U.S. business is the weak point. Same-store sales at American restaurants open at least 13 months fell 0.2%. That was better than the 0.5% decline Wall Street anticipated, but a shrinking base is not a turnaround. Traffic fell, and the company itself acknowledged that its U.S. business was falling short on execution, particularly on its value offerings, as recently as August.
CEO Chris Kempczinski said the company was encouraged by improvement as the quarter progressed. Sales returned to growth in September after declines in July and August. That is a welcome direction, but CFO Ian Borden clarified on the earnings call that he had not said U.S. same-store sales would be better in the fourth quarter. Investors should note that distinction before treating September as a trend.
The value strategy is also still being tested. McDonald's is trialing two new value menus and says the one that resonates most will roll out across the U.S. in early 2027. That timeline is a long way off for a company whose domestic customers are, by its own account, budget-conscious. Discounting has become an industry-wide habit over the last two years, and McDonald's has relied on it heavily to pull traffic back.
My view is that McDonald's should stop treating the quarter as proof that its American problem is fixing itself. The company should publish clearer U.S. traffic figures alongside same-store sales, and it should set out a near-term target for returning domestic restaurants to growth rather than pointing to the 2027 rollout. Its franchisees, who will live with whatever menu wins, deserve a firmer answer sooner.
France, where franchisees recently voted on a turnaround strategy, is a reminder that the international story is not uniformly strong either. The shares rose because the results were better than feared, not because the underlying U.S. business has recovered. Until domestic traffic grows, the beat should be read as relief rather than revival.